Evaluation Methodology
The Scientific Journal Impact Rating (SJIR) is a structured system for evaluating academic journals and assigning ratings from 1 to 10, reflecting scholarly quality, credibility, and impact. It combines quantitative metrics and qualitative assessment for a comprehensive evaluation.
Quality Factors & Weightage
Factor | Abbreviation | Weight |
Originality Contribution | OC | 50% |
Scientific Quality Contribution | SQC | 20% |
Review Process Contribution | RPC | 20% |
Regularity & Stability | RSC | 5% |
Technical Editing Quality | TEQC | 5% |
Total Quality Contributing Factor (TQCF) = OC + SQC + RPC + RSC + TEQC
Key Assessment Areas
- Originality (50 points):
Produces new knowledge, ideas, or innovations rather than reformulating existing information. - Scientific Quality (20 points):
Evaluates clarity, methodological rigor, and reproducibility of research. - Peer Review (20 points):
Measures integrity and thoroughness of the review process. - Regularity & Stability (5 points):
Consistency of publication schedules and journal longevity. - Technical Editing (5 points):
Checks formatting, tables, figures, references, typography, layout, and overall readability.
Articles Published Score (APS)
Articles Published | APS |
0–99 | 0.01 |
100–199 | 0.05 |
2000–2099 | 0.81 |
2500+ | 1.00 |
SJIR Rating = TQCF × APS
Note: Plagiarism, late publishing, or irregular issues may result in negative points affecting the final score.
Additional Criteria
- Scientific Quality: Original papers percentage, indexing, total articles published.
- Internationalization: Language of content, international editorial board, global reviewer collaboration.
- Stability: Regularity and journal age.
- Technical Quality: DOI, online access, bibliographic tools.
- Standards: Peer review, originality statements, copyright/legal compliance.
- Editorial Quality: Uniform article structure, detailed author guidelines.
- Print & Website Quality: Visuals, tables, color printing, paper quality.
Recognition
- Journals rated by SJIR may display the SJIR logo and rating on their websites.
- This signals high-quality standards, credibility, and global scholarly impact to authors, readers, and institutions.